?

Log in

No account? Create an account
March 2018   01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
NF-Lee's Gildor and Frodo

BBM Screencaps: The Kiss Scenes, Pt. IV.....

Posted on 2006.05.02 at 19:15
Tags: , , , ,
Brokeback Mountain Screencaps" ~ The Kiss Scenes, Part IV: The 'Second Tent Scene'....

In this post, I am leaving the book scene behind (which, as I wrote to Maeglian in comments for Part III, I see as very, very different). This is just about the film scene. In this scene, Ennis comes to Jack in the tent.

It is the next night....

The mood is completely different from the night before, when the two of them got drunk and slept. The night before, when Ennis' conflicted rush of feelings (in the "not-quite-a-kiss") erupted in quick, abrupt, forceful sex.

The two men have had all day to mull it over. They are glimpsed doing their separate duties, Ennis finding a slaughtered sheep, as if tangible confirmation of the wrong he thinks he has done.

A new scene opens. It's after dinner, and it's dark. Ennis lingers by the camp fire, while Jack goes into the tent.

It reminded me of hundreds of scenes when the woman goes off to the bedroom to, "slip into something more comfortable." But that was not where the movie went. The next view through the tent flaps showed that Jack shirtless, clearly waiting for Ennis to make the next move, yes. But the mood was utterly serious, not seductive or titillating.

Ennis seemed to make his decision and ambled resignedly to the tent.


* * *


Inside the tent, Jack lies waiting, reflective. The flaps part. Ennis, literally hat in hand, as if he had come courting looks humble, even repentant. He stoops to enter.

Just writing those sentences underscores what a huge thing this was for Ennis. Ennis comes to Jack almost like a supplicant. "Forgive me, Jack, for I have not treated you as you have wished or deserved." Ennis parting the flaps of the tent and his entering is redolent of millenia of symbol and image and metaphor. Not just the obvious stuff like, "flaps=vulva" -- "tent=womb" i.e. "sexual intimacy". That sense is there -- although not literally played out as male/female, of course -- but there is so much more. I could write a dissertation on it (but I promise I won't)!

I'll just observe that the image of the suitor entering the tent of the beloved, or of the priest or novice entering the tent of Mystery where the divine presence dwells, is old, very old. As old as the Hebrew scriptures, and older than that, in unrecorded human history.

As a viewer who shares in this heritage of images, how could I not be touched by the setting of this scene?


* * *


What interests me most in this scene in the film, in the light of the last discussions in this series (about Ennis' reluctance to engage either his wife or his lover face to face), is how Ennis allows himself to be drawn into Jack's embrace, face to face. It's a huge, huge step. But, still, he can't actually open his eyes.

When he first enters, his hat over his breast, he raises his eyes to Jack's but only for a brief glance. How different everything is from the night before. The tent is not pitch dark; neither of them are drunk. This is the real deal. And the both of them know it, especially Ennis, for whom the whole exchange seems almost unbearable -- yet wholly compelling.

For the rest of the scene Ennis keeps his eyes squeezed shut. But Jack's eyes are open. Unless Ennis is so close that Jack's eyes go out of focus, Jack's eyes are open: looking, inviting a return gaze. Jack is patient, as if accepting that eye contact is not yet something Ennis can bear. Jack is receptive, but watching, attending. He shows almost parental tenderness, as if aware of the huge thing this is for Ennis, to come to him, allowing himself to be seen, even if he himself can't look.


* * *


As before, I lightened and sharpened these images. The scenes were not indecipherable as in the First Tent Scene, but they were still very dark on a computer monitor.

~ unretouched screencap from this scene:









~ Screencaps from the "Second Tent Scene":































































~ Mechtild


Brokeback Mountain Links Page HERE



Comments:


Mariole
mariole at 2006-05-03 03:30 (UTC) (Link)
Ennis finding a slaughtered sheep, as tangible confirmation that he has done wrong.

That slaughtered sheep was a powerful image. To me, it symbolized Ennis' deepest fears. Later, we see the man who was dragged to death. His sprawled posture to me reminded me of the splayed limbs of the sheep, its essentials torn out. How that must have haunted Ennis. I think the sheep subconsciously reminded him of his deepest fears: This is how you will end up, if you keep doing this.

Great series, Mechtild.
Mechtild
mechtild at 2006-05-03 04:19 (UTC) (Link)
Oooh, really, really good Mariole. I'll bet you aren't the only one who leapt at that. You are right. The position of the bodies was very similar.

Again, having re-read and re-read the short story to present these caps, how differently the two presented the same love story, even if the details, even dialogue were so much the same.
(Deleted comment)
Mechtild
mechtild at 2006-05-04 01:12 (UTC) (Link)
Yes, I never made the sheep connection, image-wise. The sheep scene comes earlier in the film than the remembered hate killing. But the angle of the limbs, from memory, seems to be the same. A very interesting, subtle connection. Mariole has a really good eye for connecting images. I once saw a comparison she did at the K-D messageboard for the thread that talks about EW as an actor, parallelling shots from his earlier films with shots from LotR. Sometimes her tone was droll, but the comparison shots were really revealing.

I love the tenderness of this scene, too. It almost reminds me of a mother and child. Jack's tone of concerned attentiveness, and his careful, soothing touch as he cradles Ennis (with his closed eyes), reminds me of mothers comforting and reassuring their children when they are exhausted or troubled. It's beautifully, beautifully done, and (I think) incredibly daring. Far more than the actual sex scene. It's really a naked scene, especially for a "macho" man to do.
casey
casey28 at 2006-05-19 09:12 (UTC) (Link)
love the tenderness of this scene, too. It almost reminds me of a mother and child. Jack's tone of concerned attentiveness, and his careful, soothing touch as he cradles Ennis (with his closed eyes), reminds me of mothers comforting and reassuring their children when they are exhausted or troubled. It's beautifully, beautifully done, and (I think) incredibly daring. Far more than the actual sex scene. It's really a naked scene, especially for a "macho" man to do.

I love your description of the tenderness between Jack and Ennis. This scene grabs my heart; to see Ennis bashfully present himself to Jack, saying so much to him without uttering a single word. And Jack understands what Ennis is trying to say, and reassures him in the way you described. Or like a horse with a "low startle point", he is "steadying" Ennis, emotionally. The way they open up to each other is one of the most beautiful things that I have ever seen.
Mechtild
mechtild at 2006-05-19 13:26 (UTC) (Link)
You put that well. And the comparison to Jack's quieting horses is so good. I don't think we ever see Ennis again behave in such a vulnerable, humble manner in the film.
Previous Entry  Next Entry