Log in

No account? Create an account
March 2018   01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
NF-Lee's Gildor and Frodo

Three movies I'm glad I saw.

Posted on 2008.12.10 at 14:54


pearlette at 2008-12-13 23:48 (UTC) (Link)
Cold Mountain is one of my favourite books. My mother said it gave her nightmares! But I just loved it. The quality of the writing is exquisite. It IS extremely bleak and traumatic in places, dealing as it does with the desolation of war, but it is a truly great love story, a transcendant tale.

The film adaptation wasn't bad, but it could have been so much more, somehow. I liked Jude Law as Inman, actually: at first I had misgivings that he would be too pretty, but he acquitted himself well. Nicole and Renee were miscast, IMO.

mechtild at 2008-12-14 01:39 (UTC) (Link)
You make "Cold Mountain" sound wonderful. "A truly great love story", "a transcendant tale". Wow. How could it be these things if not set against a really dark background?
pearlette at 2008-12-14 13:01 (UTC) (Link)

Cold Mountain

It's in my top ten. :) In fact, I would probably say it's my second favourite book after LotR, it's such a powerful story and affected my imagination and heart on such a profound level.

Inman deserts the Confederate Army as he is so sick of battle and starts on the long, painful road home to the North Carolina mountains ... back to Ada, a woman to whom he wasn't even engaged when war broke out. The novel alternates chapter-by-chapter between his story and hers.

Cold Mountain is one of those books that enlarge my vision of the world. It gives a bleak and desolate picture of a country torn apart by war, it often portrays men and women behaving in bestial ways ... but that isn't the whole picture. Inman and Ada, who hardly know each other and yet have grown to love each other deeply, seek to rise above the forces of death and brutality all around them. There is redemption and hope, and not just in the deep love of Ada and Inman, but also in the sharp, practical, earthy, deeply kind person of Ruby.

Cold Mountain has been compared to The Odyssey, because of its mythic power, and it fully deserves the comparison.

It's a FANTASTIC book! :)

The film was good, but not great. The book is truly great.
mechtild at 2008-12-14 14:13 (UTC) (Link)

Re: Cold Mountain

It sounds like a film version would never live up to it. Yet it could still have been a great film, thinking of LotR. The films didn't live up to Tolkien's book, either, but the attempt produced great films.
pearlette at 2008-12-14 17:07 (UTC) (Link)

Re: Cold Mountain

It sounds like a film version would never live up to it. Yet it could still have been a great film, thinking of LotR. The films didn't live up to Tolkien's book, either, but the attempt produced great films.

Exactly. :)

No film version could ever match the version of LotR in my head, or the visions that book produces in my mind. I know that, surely every Tolkien fan knows that. Yet we still hoped for, and expected, greatness from PJ's films, and that is what he delivered, even despite some of the liberties he took. There are many things I forgive him for.

I do think the film adaptation of Cold Mountain could have matched the book, actually. As it was, it missed the book's transcendant quality. Nicole and Jude somehow failed to elevate the great romance at the heart of the book to the greatness it deserved on screen. I'm not saying it would have been easy: in the book, the two lovers do not meet until the final part! But the reader gets to know both of them, intimately, as the story progresses, and you are totally rooting for their love to succeed, against devastating odds.

By the way, I have adjusted my viewing screen to fix the problem I had with viewing your journal: the font now appears a perfectly normal size and I am no longer squinting. Why I didn't think to do this before, I don't know.

mechtild at 2008-12-14 18:30 (UTC) (Link)

Re: Cold Mountain

What did you do to your viewing screen, then? I remember you saying it only behaved this way viewing this journal, which was why I didn't suggest going to "View" on the menu bar, then adjusting the text size.

You are really making me want to read this book, but I don't have time. I checked out but never read the last books you got me excited over: same thing. Not enough time. And I haven't even had a job outside the house this fall. I do take a lot of time preparing posts, it's true. If I would just pull back on those, I'd have a lot more writing and reading time. Of course, those do involve writing and reading, so it's not as though it's time wasted. :) But you know what I mean: reading stuff I've never read before, rather than things I've read many times. I've been reading non-fiction when I'm not preparing posts, mostly. I did read the McMaster Vorkossigan series in the summer, per Estelanui's recommendations. It was fun, but one read was enough.

ETA: I should add that I did manage to read some mysteries by favourite mystery authors whose work I hadn't kept up on, because of being involved in LJ and LotR stuff the past few years. When I was convalescing this fall, I read the most recent volumes of Martha Grimes and P. D. James. But the books of both were very disappointing. Not so much the penultimate P. D. James and Grimes, but their last ones. It made me sad. It was as if they really had nothing else to say through their featured protagonists, they were just turning out books to meet their contract stipulations.

Edited at 2008-12-14 06:36 pm (UTC)
pearlette at 2008-12-14 19:24 (UTC) (Link)

Fixing the font

I used 'Zoom' under 'View' on the Menu bar. Rather to my surprise, the zooming stayed put, rather than be temporary! I don't pretend to understand it, but it's working. :)

As for having time to read ... well, I commute every day, so I have time to read. I'm lucky. :)

Although I don't post half so much as I used to, if I posted less, I would write more.

I would have written a lot more LotR fanfiction back in the day had it not been for my intense involvement in the messageboards. The discussions were too fascinating, the people were too much fun ... so I blame you lot. :p

Kidding. :)

But writing takes serious time and energy. It's not surprising I don't get more done.
mechtild at 2008-12-14 19:57 (UTC) (Link)

Re: Fixing the font

The discussions were too fascinating, the people were too much fun ... so I blame you lot. :p

But you're right, though. Still, I wouldn't have missed it for anything.
pearlette at 2008-12-14 23:29 (UTC) (Link)
No, neither would I!
Previous Entry  Next Entry